A.O.C. Had a Catchy Logo. Now Progressives Everywhere Are Copying It.

The slanted text in Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez’s logo, and its break from the traditional red, white and blue color palette, has formed a new graphical language for progressivism. Imitators abound.

Advertisement

Continue reading the main story

Supported by

Continue reading the main story

In her three years in the national spotlight, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez has become the undisputed face of unabashed progressivism. But there is another hidden-in-plain-sight legacy of her 2018 primary victory: Her campaign logo and poster have reshaped the visual branding of the left.

Candidates across the country, and even internationally, have appropriated elements of its condensed and bold typeface and its upward-sloping, dialog-box design.

Imitations and inspirations have appeared in the governor’s race in Virginia, a Senate contest in Kentucky, an elementary school race in Queens and even a campaign by a communist candidate in France.

The trend is perhaps most intense in and around New York, where local races are littered with candidates who have tilted the text on their logos upward

— including two candidates running for the same City Council seat that overlaps with Ms. Ocasio-Cortez’s district.

Some campaigns even adjusted their original, more straightforward logos to her slant shortly after she won her primary.

If Donald J. Trump redefined the red hat as a symbol of the right, Ms. Ocasio-Cortez’s slant and her break from the traditional red, white and blue color palette has formed something of a new graphical language for progressivism. Political designers say her logo’s vibe has come to convey insurgency, youth, diversity, liberalism — and winning.

“What A.O.C. did is she changed what it is to run for office,” said Amoy Barnes, a 34-year-old Black Democrat running for City Council on Staten Island. When Ms. Barnes’s consulting firm presented her a set of past political logos to provide inspiration, she immediately gravitated toward the Ocasio-Cortez design. “Being a young woman of color with her bright purple and the slant and her full name — she set a bar to say we don’t have to do things the same way.”

Gavan Fitzsimons, a professor in the business school at Duke University who studies the impact of branding in the unconscious minds of voters and consumers, said that familiar design can trigger powerful associations.

“Voters that see those elements are unlikely, at least initially, to notice the similarity with the A.O.C. design,” Mr. Fitzsimons explained. But, he added, “what happens cognitively is it shines a light in your head.”

“Essentially what they are doing is borrowing from all the work she has done on the progressive side of the Democratic Party,” he said of look-alike logos.

The distinctive A.O.C. typography has even found itself on T-shirts sold by politicians of both parties — serving as a visual shorthand of sorts for the left.

Senator Bernie Sanders, whose 2016 presidential bid inspired Ms. Ocasio-Cortez’s own political career, is using it to sell shirts supporting the Green New Deal (the signature policy initiative of Ms. Ocasio-Cortez).

Image

Senator Bernie Sanders’s Green New Deal shirt features bold, slanted typography.

Image

A shirt for Sarah Huckabee Sanders’s campaign for governor features a similar aesthetic to mock the left.

While Sarah Huckabee Sanders, the former White House press secretary for Mr. Trump now running for governor of Arkansas, has adopted the tilted text for her anti-left clothing line demanding, “Let’s cancel cancel culture.”

All of which has been amusing to the design team that created Ms. Ocasio-Cortez’s logo, and who have begun cataloging various duplications that pop up on the campaign trail and in popular culture. “They’re everywhere,” said Scott Starrett, who helped design her logo. “Finding them is actually quite fun now.”

Mr. Starrett socialized with Ms. Ocasio-Cortez before she was “A.O.C.” — in an interview he kept lapsing into referring to her as Sandy, as her pre-politics friends and family knew her — and said they had discussed her ideology long before he and Maria Arenas at the design firm Tandem sketched out her logo.

The color palette and speech bubble in the final design drew inspiration from Rosie the Riveter, Mr. Starrett said. The poster with her outward gaze was drawn from a Cesar Chavez stamp. And the overall look came from boxing, farmworker unionizing and luchador posters.

Image

Ms. Ocasio-Cortez’s campaign poster for the Democratic primary in 2018.

Image

Ian Brossat of France used slanted text and bold colors in a losing bid for European Parliament.

The inverted exclamation mark with a star punctuated her Puerto Rican heritage, and simultaneously turned her name into a rallying cry. “We wanted this idea that she was shouting her name to get attention, and also the idea that people were shouting her name,” Mr. Starrett said.

The slant and condensed font, though, was as much a typographical necessity as anything. Mr. Starrett said they had lobbied for not spelling out her full name, but Ms. Ocasio-Cortez held firm. She wanted her whole name. They tilted and stacked it to make it fit.

“The way she went with that angled typography, that has entered the vernacular,” said Sol Sender, who led the design team that created former President Barack Obama’s famous 2008 logo — a red, white and blue “O” for his name, and a rising sun, signifying a new day — which itself spurred a raft of copycats.

When Melquiades Gagarin began his own 2020 long-shot primary challenge for Congress in a Queens congressional district neighboring Ms. Ocasio-Cortez’s, his logo intentionally embraced the upward slope.

Mr. Gagarin called it “an homage to the A.O.C. campaign” itself but also the “activist, progressive spirit” that she embodies. Splashed across his website was a photo of Mr. Gagarin gazing off into the distance, just as Ms. Ocasio-Cortez had in her signature posters.

“It almost came to be a joke,” Mr. Gagarin laughingly said, “that if you weren’t looking off to a distance you weren’t a progressive candidate.”

Mr. Gagarin lost, as insurgents often do. One winner: Magdalena Pena, whose copycat design and bid for first-grade class senator at her elementary school in Queens won praise from Ms. Ocasio-Cortez herself earlier this year.

“I love it!” she wrote approvingly in a tweet. (Ms. Ocasio-Cortez declined an interview request for this article.)

Not all imitators were intentional. The logo for Mondaire Jones, a progressive that Ms. Ocasio-Cortez endorsed last year, tilts upward, but his campaign manager said it was produced by a volunteer and any similarity was unintended.

Erik Bottcher, a council candidate in Manhattan, had simply asked his political team to create a look that was “something forward-facing and hopeful and exuberant and energetic” — and this is what they came up with.

Many knowingly embraced her design. “It was intentional for me,” said Jesse Laymon, a Democrat running for City Council in Queens. “The slant — I would credit as AOC-inspired.”

As impressed as Mr. Sender was with Ms. Ocasio-Cortez’s iconography — “she was announcing herself as a candidate that was going to stand for something different — and the whole design language supported that” — he is disappointed at the glut of imitators.

“Dig deeper,” he urged fellow designers. “Come on, don’t you have your own ideas?”

Almost no design is truly original. Others have used angled text before — including the Clinton-Gore ticket in 1992. And some archconservative Republicans are still using it now, including Trump-aligned Representative Mo Brooks, who is running for Senate in Alabama.

The Ocasio-Cortez logo was distinctive not just for the slant of the text. It also featured an unusual-for-politics color scheme of purple and yellow.

“There’s really a struggle with embracing red, white and blue,” said Tarik Nally, a designer based in Louisville. “Not because we don’t love our country or colors. But because that can be considered establishment.”

Mr. Nally crafted the logo for Charles Booker, an insurgent Democrat who ran for Senate in Kentucky in 2020. He used purple and yellow and Ms. Ocasio-Cortez’s signature upward tilt.

“Progress and increase and movement and upward momentum,” Mr. Nally said. “It just felt right.” Mr. Booker lost in the party’s primary last year but is considering running again in 2022.

Ahead of her 2020 re-election, Ms. Ocasio-Cortez queried her team about redesigning the logo to “stay ahead of the curve,” as Mr. Starrett described it. He successfully rebuffed the idea, making the case that the original logo was still shaping the curve.

Image

Michelle Caruso-Cabrera, a candidate for New York City comptroller, previously challenged Ms. Ocasio-Cortez in a Democratic primary for her congressional seat.Credit…Gabriela Bhaskar for The New York Times

That race only reinforced the power of Ms. Ocasio-Cortez’s design. She faced a primary battle against the former CNBC journalist Michelle Caruso-Cabrera, whose logo was flat with a blue forward arrow.

Ms. Ocasio-Cortez won in a landslide. Now Ms. Caruso-Cabrera is running for New York City comptroller — and has refreshed her logo to tilt upward, mirroring the woman she had run against.

“First time I’ve thought about that,” Ms. Caruso-Cabrera said when asked about the logo similarities as she walked through the Union Square farmers’ market on one recent afternoon. “The upward tilt,” she said, “was always about optimism.”

Moments later, a young woman walked past carrying a canvas sack of groceries, and wearing a yellow Ocasio-Cortez T-shirt.

Kitty Bennett contributed research.

Image

Ms. Caruso-Cabrera’s logo during her 2020 primary challenge against Ms. Ocasio-Cortez.

Image

Ms. Caruso-Cabrera’s redesigned logo for her 2021 run for city comptroller.

Leave a Reply